Spoiler Alert
This post may contain spoilers. Read at your own risk.
I just finished reading The Last Hope yesterday, and was quite shocked to find that the fourth cat was not anyone I'd thought it might be in my earlier posts, but in fact Firestar. A reader who mentioned the fact to me said it was cliché, and I agree wholeheartedly. I personally think he was far too old for this role; he was on his last life and the Clans needed all four cats stated in the prophecy to be around for their reconstruction. At the end of the book he loses his final life; and when I read it I found myself shocked that the Erins would kill off Firestar, who was obviously Warriors' big hero. But his being the fourth cat irritated me to no end. I'm not happy with the way that turned out, I would've thought a more younger and vivacious cat would step up to the plate. But as always, it had to be Firestar to come in and save the day. Talk about cliché! (ooh, that rhymed. xD)
However, the one part of the book that I enjoyed the most was when Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight became mates again and Brambleclaw was appointed leader (Squirrelflight deputy). As you guys no doubt already know, I am a huge supporter of Bramblestar and have wanted him to become leader for a long time. I'm so glad he finally has! c: It was also nice to see Dovewing settle down with Bumblestripe - although my hypothesis from over a year ago was incorrect, it was nice to see her get a mate (after all, she is Dovewing, and that task probably isn't the easiest thing for her to do). And the best part of the book was that StarClan won! However, I can't stop myself from wondering what would've happened if the Dark Forest had won... it would make for an interesting fanfic!
What was your opinion on The Last Hope? Did you like the ending? Did you think Firestar was a good pick for the fourth cat? What do you think would've happened if the Dark Forest had won? Do you have any more opinions you'd like to share? Post it all in your comments.
~Smoketail
